Do you need a car in Madeira?
If you want to see the whole island on your own schedule, yes, rent one. If you are staying in Funchal, or you are nervous about steep narrow roads and hairpin bends, you can have an excellent trip without one. The terrain, not the distance, is what decides it.
I drive this island for a living, so you would expect me to tell you not to rent a car. I am not going to. For a lot of trips, renting is the right call and I say so.
Rent a car if
You are staying more than three or four days, you want to move at your own pace, and you are comfortable driving on steep narrow roads with a manual gearbox or paying more for an automatic.
You are based outside Funchal. Public transport between the smaller towns exists but it is built for residents, not for sightseeing, and it will shape your day more than you want.
You like stopping. Half the good things here are viewpoints you did not plan on.
Do not bother if
You are in Funchal for a short stay. The old town, the market, the cable car and the seafront are all walkable, and taxis for the rest are straightforward.
You are not a confident driver on gradients. This is the honest one. Madeira's terrain is demanding, with steep inclines and narrow roads that are hard work in a low-powered rental car. If that sentence makes you tense, the trip will be better without it.
You are here for two or three days and want to cover the island. That is the case where a driver or a guided day earns its cost, because the driving is the tiring part and it eats the time you came for.
What the roads are actually like
Modern, well maintained, and steeper than almost anywhere you have driven. The main routes are fast dual carriageway and long tunnels. The moment you leave them for a village or a viewpoint, you get single track with a drop on one side.
Parking in Funchal is the other thing people underestimate. It is tight, it is mostly paid, and in the old town it is largely a matter of luck.
What about the hop-on hop-off bus?
It exists in Funchal and it does what it says. It will show you the city and get you to Monte. It will not show you the island, and nothing that leaves from a bus stop will.
The middle option
Plenty of people rent for part of the trip and not all of it. A car for the days you want to roam, and a guided day for the long west loop or the pre-dawn run up to Pico do Arieiro, where the driving is the least enjoyable part.
If you do come out with me, pickup is included from Funchal, Camara de Lobos and Canico, and I can collect from elsewhere on the island for a supplement.
Common questions
Do you need a car in Madeira?
Is driving in Madeira difficult?
Should I get an automatic car in Madeira?
Is parking difficult in Funchal?
Is there a hop-on hop-off bus in Funchal?
Planning a trip and want a second opinion? Tell me your dates and a bit about who is coming, and I will come back within 24 hours.